Monday, November 16, 2026

What Minnesota Can Learn from a High Performing School




In our last post, we promised to take a close look at a school with a demonstrated record of success with lower-income students, English language learners and students of color. The school is Brooke Charter Schools, a network of public charter schools in Boston. I chose to highlight Brooke because it:

  1. Persistently produces outstanding results.
  2. Provides its students with about 30 percent more learning time than a typical Minnesota district such as St. Cloud, the equivalent of about 52 more school days a year.
  3. Makes an unparalleled investment in recruiting and continually developing its teachers, supported by peer observations, co-planning and data meetings focused on what students need.

1. Persistent results in a state that sets the bar high

Brooke serves about 2,200 students in grades K-12. More than ninety percent are Black and/or Latinx, drawn mainly from Dorchester, Mattapan, Hyde Park, East Boston, Roxbury and Chelsea. In its 2019-20 annual report, Brooke reported that the average annual income of its families was $38,000. Admission is by random lottery, open to all Boston and Chelsea students, including English learners and students with disabilities.

Before looking at results, a word about the measuring stick. "Proficient" in Massachusetts does not mean the same thing as "proficient" in Minnesota. The National Center for Education Statistics regularly maps each state's proficiency standard onto the scale of the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), the common national yardstick. In the 2024 preliminary mapping, Massachusetts' proficiency standard matched NAEP Proficient in reading and math in both grade 4 and grade 8. Minnesota's standard mapped to NAEP Basic in all four. Massachusetts has been at or near the top of these rankings for nearly twenty years. A Brooke student who scores proficient on the Massachusetts MCAS has cleared a higher bar than a Minnesota student who scores proficient on the MCA.

Against that high bar, Brooke reports:

  • Brooke is in the top five in Massachusetts for student growth in both English and math, grades 3-8 (2024 MCAS).
  • More Black students exceed expectations than in all of the other Boston Public Schools, grades 3-8 combined (2024 MCAS).
  • It was designated as a Massachusetts School of Recognition in 2025.
  • It is one of the top two open-enrollment high schools in Boston, and the only Massachusetts school in which every member of the class of 2020 scored advanced or proficient on the high school MCAS.

Brooke's English learners also progress unusually fast. In the state's 2026 accountability report, Brooke's English learners and former English learners in grades 3-8 posted the strongest math growth of any student group in the school. And Brooke's reading scores keep pace with its math scores: "Our kids do well on tests because they love reading."

The results have also lasted. When then-state Commissioner Mitchell Chester supported Brooke's expansion into high school, he said it would be hard to overstate Brooke's track record. Brooke's first graduating class, in 2020, sent 89 percent of its seniors to college, with acceptances at 112 different colleges.

There are some caveats:

  • The pandemic hurt Brooke too. Its statewide percentile fell from the 92nd to the 81st in math, and from the 87th to the 81st in English, between 2019 and 2022. Brooke's students, however, are still performing in the top fifth of the state.
  • Families choose to apply. Admission is by lottery, but only applicants enter it.
  • Brooke's student population differs somewhat from the Boston Public Schools. According to the state, about 10.6 percent of Brooke's students are English learners, 16.5 percent are students with disabilities, and 61.2 percent are low income.

But the state's growth data accounts for student differences. Massachusetts measures each student's growth against students across the state who started with similar test scores. In 2026, Brooke's students in grades 3-8 grew faster than typical in both reading and math, and so did its English learners and its students with disabilities. Brooke's English learners posted the strongest math growth of any group in the school. Compared with high-needs students in similar schools statewide, Brooke's high-needs students ranked in the 96th percentile.  



2. More time to learn: 30 percent more than St. Cloud and other Minnesota public schools

If a student arrives a year or more behind, as many do, what makes us think he can catch up with more advantaged classmates in the same amount of time? To be frank, in Minnesota this is a topic we refuse even to consider: in essence, our answer is based on convenience for adults, not for the students who are behind.

Brooke's answer is to give students significantly more learning time. Brooke's K-8 students start at 7:45 a.m. and are dismissed at 4:00 p.m. on Mondays, Tuesdays, Thursdays and Fridays. On Wednesdays they are dismissed at 12:20 p.m. so teachers can spend the afternoon on professional development and collaboration. Brooke East Boston's 2026-27 calendar runs from August 12, 2026 to June 17, 2027: 191 school days for grades 1-8.

Using my own district as a Minnesota example, here is how that compares with St. Cloud's elementary schools:



Note what Brooke does with its Wednesdays. It gives up 37 student afternoons a year so teachers can work together, and it still provides far more student time than St. Cloud does.

3. Great teachers are made, not born

Brooke's philosophy starts from a simple premise: teaching is an intellectual profession, and great teachers are developed throughout their careers, not discovered. There is no presumption that a teaching degree alone produces great teaching. Brooke builds its own pipeline through its Associate Teacher Program, a year-long, school-based residency founded in 2006:

  • Associates are paid a full $60,000 salary with benefits during their training year.
  • They begin with a full month of professional development, then attend weekly seminars throughout the year.
  • Each Associate has an experienced teacher-coach who observes, mentors and evaluates them monthly.
  • They gain classroom experience by teaching parts of lessons and covering classes, taking on more responsibility as they grow.

The program is also designed to diversify the teaching workforce, and it works: about 30 percent of Brooke's current staff began as Associates, including at least one current principal. Hiring itself is rigorous. Candidates go through a phone screen, a panel interview with current teachers, and an in-person demonstration lesson with students. All new teachers, not just Associates, get a month of training before their first school year.

4. Teachers learning from teachers: observation and collaboration

Brooke's support does not end after the first year. Every teacher, novice or veteran, receives:

  • At least 20 observations a year by principals and assistant principals, each followed by prompt feedback. Compare that with Minnesota, where state law requires only one formal evaluation of an experienced teacher every three years. National surveys find that most teachers receive observation feedback about once a year, and more than four in ten never observe a colleague's classroom in a typical month (RAND American Teacher Panel).
  • Peer observations and video analysis of their own teaching.
  • About three hours of professional development and collaboration every Wednesday afternoon.
  • Regular co-planning with same-grade colleagues, and data meetings to review student progress and adjust instruction.


Brooke also made a structural choice that supports all this collaboration. Its middle grades are organized like an elementary school: students stay with the same teacher for most of the day in self-contained classrooms. Administrator Steadman pushed for the change after noticing that Brooke's elementary teachers, who planned together by grade level, were more satisfied than middle school subject specialists. The model gives every grade a team of teachers planning the same lessons together. It also means students are known well by the adults who teach them. Brooke founder Jon Clark has said that if you asked Brooke teachers what most pushes them to get better, they would name having a smart colleague to plan with and to study data with.

In my first post in this series, I pointed out that only 15-20 percent of Minneapolis Black students score proficient in reading. Suppose we knew in Minnesota that implementing a robust plan like this would dramatically increase the number of successful students. Would we be willing to try that with a few Minnesota schools to see if it actually works? Would we be willing to pay for it? And, would teaching be a whole lot more satisfying for those who teach under that system?

5. What does it cost?

Brooke's 2019-20 annual report showed total revenue of about $47.6 million for 1,970 students, roughly $24,200 per student. That figure includes about $8.9 million in transportation and pension costs paid on Brooke's behalf. Federal finance data (NCES F-33, fiscal 2022) put Brooke's per-pupil spending at about $24,100, compared with about $20,300 for St. Cloud ISD 742. That is roughly $3,800, or 19 percent, more per student.

Three things stand out:

  • The gap is modest in dollars. Brooke is not lavishly funded compared with St. Cloud.
  • A dollar buys less in Boston. Boston is far more expensive than St. Cloud, and Brooke's budget also carries about $7 million a year in facility costs.
  • Brooke can direct its money where it believes it matters. It spends on time and on teachers: 30 percent more learning time, a paid residency, intensive coaching and built-in collaboration. It has the freedom to set its own calendar, school day and staffing, without having to bargain each change separately.

This is the point I have been making for years. Money makes a difference in education when it is used effectively. But simply sending more money to districts is unlikely to produce Brooke-like results unless the money buys the things that work, and unless districts have the authority and the vision to buy them. Minnesota must change how we deliver education and pay for it at the same time.

6. The rest of the Brooke model

Time, money and teacher development are the parts of Brooke's model that require policy change. Brooke's success also depends on what happens in the classroom:

  • Putting the thinking on students. Brooke rejects the "I do, we do, you do" lesson, in which students watch the teacher solve a problem and then imitate it. Lessons begin with an unfamiliar problem that students attack using what they already know. Then teachers lead a discussion that compares students' strategies, draws connections between them and corrects misconceptions. Mastery means applying an idea to a significantly different problem, not repeating the same one. One benefit: Brooke students don't panic when a state test presents a problem they haven't seen before.
  • Literacy taught as a love of reading. Brooke teaches phonics like any good school, but you will not find reading worksheets there. When a student struggles, teachers first ask why the student doesn't love reading, and work to unlock that love.
  • Challenged and known. Brooke's two pillars are that every student should be academically challenged and personally known by the adults in the building.
  • A culture of achievement. Brooke makes its expectation that every student will achieve explicit and celebrates it publicly. Yet it avoids the rigid, scripted "no excuses" discipline found in some high-performing charters.
  • A shared instructional system. Teachers across the network use common lesson structures, curricula and tools, so effective techniques become shared craft. Brooke publishes more than 100 classroom videos and its curricular materials on its resources site. Minnesota educators can watch them today, free.
  • English learners and students with disabilities supported inside the regular classroom. English learner coordinators, special educators and classroom teachers plan together, while students keep full access to grade-level work. English learner coordinators stay with the same students and families for years.
  • Teachers, not programs. Brooke deliberately avoids layering on intervention programs and computer-based instruction. It invests instead in the quality of classroom teaching.
  • Stable leadership. Jon Clark has led Brooke since 2002 and Kimberly Steadman since 2004. Brooke has spent two decades refining one coherent model rather than cycling through initiatives.

Can we do this here?

Some of Brooke's practices cost nothing but will and skill. Any Minnesota school could start putting the thinking on students tomorrow, and Brooke has published its materials to help. But the foundation of Brooke's success is more time for students, a serious investment in developing teachers, and protected time for teachers to learn from each other. That foundation costs money, and it requires structural change: longer school days and years, a different use of teacher time, and the authority to organize schools around what works.

Minnesota's current funding system gives districts neither the resources nor the structure to build that foundation. If we are serious about closing the gaps our schools now accept as normal, we need to design the education our students need, calculate what it costs, and fund it. Brooke shows that the results are worth it.

What Minnesota Can Learn from a High Performing School

In our last post, we promised to take a close look at a school with a demonstrated record of success with lower-income students, English l...